[Rhodes22-list] Rhodes List- Robertson's Rules Of Order

[Jim White]

Ben:
 
Seems like this list has been down this exact Rhode once or twice before....
 
I am a fairly recent member of the list, having only been here since about 2004 or so.... owning my little splendid Le Menagerie (along with a menagerie of other boats) since then. But my 2 cents worth is that this list has always included much more than just sailing and specifically Rhodes material. It's the sailors bar aspect that I find probably equally appealing to the techinical aspect. Heck, my R22 has been about hassle free (especially compared to the big complex Pearson I usually drive with it's myriad of systems....so most of that info I usually shine on anyway.....
 
Come to think about it this is the most free time I have to drop and and give my darn 2 cents worth recently.....But I always feel akin to, especially the list members (like the Rummy-man) who helped me out so much in the beginning....
 
FWIW, my vote....Let the list be free....no restrictions.
 
Capt. jw

--- On Thu, 12/17/09, BenCittadino <bencittadino at gmail.com> wrote:


From: BenCittadino <bencittadino at gmail.com>
Subject: [Rhodes22-list] Rhodes List- Robertson's Rules Of Order
To: rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org
Date: Thursday, December 17, 2009, 3:28 PM



Rhodies;

It's almost winter, so we may as well deal with this issue. Frankly, it
doesn't matter to me that much which way we go but I would like to get it
settled to avoid arguments in the future. But Al's most recent missive
suggests we ought to talk some about this.

Is it the opinion of the people who post here that the posts should relate
to sailing only, or does the "anything that might come up in a sailor's bar"
model suit most of us best?

I agree with Al that the list should not become dominated by extraneous
stuff, but frankly I think allowing for friendly chatter helps us get to
know each other and might even create a synergistic bonding or fraternal
aspect that might encourage more socializing with our boats.

If posts about sailing slow down during the winter months folks might drift
away from the list and not be available when we need advice.

I also don't see the "clutter our mailboxes" argument as I get my list
digested and can pick and choose what I read. 

Frankly, when the political debates were raging during the election
knowledgable guys like Ed were available at a moment's notice to chime in on
the sailing stuff, albeit his advice was often "check the archives!!!"

I personally love the jokes, stories, and occasional sports references, and
other tidbits I learn about my fellow sailors. 

I propose a robust debate on how the list should work vis-a-vis subject
matter and that we informally agree that once a consensus appears the rest
of us tacitly agree to abide by it. 

I like the open-forum model. What do YOU think?

BenCittadino
s/v susan kay  
-- 
View this message in context: http://old.nabble.com/Rhodes-List--Robertson%27s-Rules-Of-Order-tp26835266p26835266.html
Sent from the Rhodes 22 mailing list archive at Nabble.com.

__________________________________________________
To subscribe/unsubscribe go to http://www.rhodes22.org/mailman/listinfo/rhodes22-list

For the list Charter and help with using the mailing list and archives go to http://www.rhodes22.org/list
__________________________________________________